Review the proposal
Specific questions make useful review.
O2AT is an engineering draft. Reviews are most useful when they identify a section, provide evidence and explain the compatibility effect of a proposed change.
Review scope
Start with the wire behaviour.
- Can two independent teams implement the fixed header, descriptors, state transitions and counter semantics without interpreting unstated defaults?
- Are MTU, VLAN, padding, FCS and occupied-time calculations correct for the stated MAC service?
- Do credit updates account for sent-but-not-yet-consumed data and keep packet events causal under delay?
- Are source pacing, common-frequency operation and fixed-rate live input distinguished accurately?
- Can the reference-loss and holdover policy be tested without relying on remote STATUS delivery for local protection?
- Does a proposed change affect header interpretation, capability negotiation, packet sizing, clock state or interoperability?
Contribution route
Use the public issue tracker.
Use the project’s public GitHub issue tracker for technical review and reproducible defects. Do not include private equipment, infrastructure details, access tokens or unpublished customer information.
Open a review issueView the project repository
Submission does not imply adoption. A protocol change is accepted only in a numbered revision with an explicit compatibility note and updated test vectors. Review comments remain distinguishable from adopted requirements.
Governance and licences
Open review is not certification.
The v0.2 paper proposes open software/RTL and hardware licensing directions. The website code, specification prose, any future RTL or hardware files, third-party standards, trademarks and vendor materials are distinct works. A proposed licence does not establish patent clearance or grant rights over third-party material.
Project initiator and author: Tunji Durodola. The paper is currently a proposal for review. No manufacturer endorsement, independent peer review or standards approval is represented here.